New Rubric idea.

So, our current rubric isn't detailed enough and just feels lack luster. So, this is what I think the new rubric should be.

Creativity: 0/20 How original the deck

Competitiveness: 0/20 How well the deck can stand in a duel

Misplays: 0/10 How many misplays or corrections they needed. If called a tester on a misplay, you gain 1+ bonus points per misplay called.

Adaptability: 0/20 How well you felt they adapted to the shift in battle and power

Card usages: 0/20 Did they use their card effects to their full advantage or did they do any original combos?

Siding: 0/15 How well you felt that they side and did the siding cards actually come in handy?

Deck consistency: 0/20 How well you felt the deck played, did it run well or just felt like a broken down car constantly shifting from working to bad?

Overall skill: 0/20 How well the duelist preformed as a duelist? Did he try his best and constantly think of ideas?  

Match score: 0/30
0=X,X
10=O,X,X
20=O,X,O
30=O,O

Total score: 0/175

Slifer: 0-72

Ra: 73-144

Obelisk: 145-175

So, guys what do you think? Anything you feel can be added or taken off and if need be, we can make the points higher.

Rulings.
Also, what happens if you lose, win, win or lose, win, lose, as you don't have it one there.

jackachu100 wrote:Rulings.
Also, what happens if you lose, win, win or lose, win, lose, as you don't have it one there.

It was just an example, any tester can figure out what I was talking about.

dude, if you're gonna change the score, you cant just make slifer and ra 72 points wide, then obelisk 40. you gotta devide it up equally. i say we should keep the rubric as it is now.

Why Creativity somepeople like basing their decks off of other things you cant blame them for that

I like how creativity and competitive is separated L O L.

actully now there the same

lolw/e. but i like the rubric XD

The rubric is fine as it is.

which rubric moon old or new

This idea seems ok but I think we should have creativity,competitiveness and maybe originality in the same category. Other than that it should be fine.

can u make another catogory called How much fun they had

darkphoenix wrote:This idea seems ok but I think we should have creativity,competitiveness and maybe originality in the same category. Other than that it should be fine.

Effectively, this.

Tsukuyomi the Moon mistre wrote:

darkphoenix wrote:This idea seems ok but I think we should have creativity,competitiveness and maybe originality in the same category. Other than that it should be fine.

Effectively, this.

I agree with phonix

You really can't have competitiveness and creativity in the same category, THEY ARE COMPLETELY TWO DIFFERENT THINGS. Just because a deck is competitive, doesn't make it creative and vice versa. A truly skilled duelist can make a deck mixed with both aspects.  Give a reasonable reason why the two should be mixed? I see no reason WHY IT SHOULD EVER BE MIXED.

For those who don't know what they really mean... here's the definitions of both creativity and competitiveness...

cre·a·tiv·i·ty
ˌkrē-āˈtivitē/Submit
noun
1.
the use of the imagination or original ideas, esp. in the production of an artistic work.

competitiveness
Web definitions
an aggressive willingness to compete; "the team was full of fight"

both definitions are thanks to Google.